While I enjoy snazzy, overpriced thrift stores in New York as much as the next person -- walking around definitely made me hangry after a while, and to my delight, Vinnie's Pizzeria was just down the street (and was a restaurant I had added to our New York itinerary). It was almost like I was destined to try Vinnie's. Space was tight; I probably saw about three tables present, and it was around 2 pm, so it was not as busy. Overall, the vibes were cozy, and the worker taking my order had a bright, infectious energy, so the service was top-notch! I ordered an Elote pizza and KBBQ-inspired pizza, both unique flavors. Two large slices were $12, so I like to think I got my money's worth. - Elote Pizza: (4/5) While the pizza was delicious, I hoped for more of a "punch" in flavor. The Elote taste was rather subtle and, at times, tasted more like cheese pizza with corn on top. The addition of chili flakes helps, though! Regardless, I found the slice enjoyable, not too heavy/greasy, and I recommend that others try it. A safe but unique option. - KBBQ/Spicy Korean Pizza: (3.75/5): This was a brand new flavor, and where else am I going to find KBBQ-inspired pizza? So I bit the bullet and ordered it. Interestingly enough, this one had the opposite problem from the Elote pizza because it had a very STRONG flavor that was almost overwhelming. I don't remember the exact ingredients, but I recall a BBQ sauce drizzle and crispy onion flakes on top, which was a nice addition! There was a spicy kick as well. It was enjoyable for a bit, but I found the pizza to be borderline salty at times, so it's not something I'd order again. There was an evident KBBQ taste, however, which was fun! But a cup of complimentary water would have been greatly appreciated... Some of my friends had differing opinions, but I think Vinnie's Pizzeria is worth stopping by!

Get the Cowboy Pizza! Came with some friends for a quick lunch. Two of my friends were vegan, which was great because they had a pretty good variety of vegan and vegetarian pizzas. I tried a bit of everyone's pizza but I personally ordered two slices, the Cowboy and Buffalo Chicken, for $12 and found the portions to be very filling. Overall I enjoyed the pizzas and would come again! - The Cowboy(4.5/5): This was by far my favorite slice. It's packed with so much flavor and has this incredible sauce that's creamy and smoky. It was also loaded with a generous amount of juicy meat and red peppers. The crust was also cooked perfectly, thin and crispy, very authentic to the New York style. - Buffalo Chicken Pizza (2/5): This pizza was just a bit lacking. I found the chicken to be very dry and even picked them off at one point. My friend did like it though and the sauce was good. - Other pizzas: my vegan friends really liked the Spare Ribs and Pineapple vegan pizza, but found the other two vegan pizza flavors that they ordered (buffalo chicken and eggplant parm) to be unpleasant. My other friend got the Elote pizza and a newer flavor that was inspired by KBBQ. I tried both of her's and liked them, especially the Elote pizza which had a nice sweet and salty flavor combination. - Service/ambiance: really good vibes here. It's a cute small pizza shop that has cool decor. The employees are also all super nice and friendly, it feels super wholesome. Shout out to the guy behind the counter who had this great infectious energy!

We were told by a local New Yorker that this is a go-to pizza spot. It did not disappoint! Perfect crunchy/chewy crust, pizza sauce with a bit of spice, and variety of topping choices.

So my family was staying far away from here, but I got a recommendation for here from my teacher who grew up in Brooklyn. We walked an hour just for this, and it was worth it. The service was great. They were so nice to us. The food came out piping hot, and it was great. Th cheese was good, the the sauce was amazing, and the crust had a perfect crunch to it. The ambiance was also really fun. They had old pictures and things about Vinnies. Totally worth it

My favorite pizza shop! Small inside but the pizza is worth the crowd. Staff is always so nice and has a great vibe. My go-to is the elote slice. Absolutely slaps. They have all the fixings on the side as well including hot sauce, barbecue sauce, Parmesan, etc. They are open late on weekends and give a discount if you pay in cash!

From local New Yorkers, this pizza slaps! Love the energy & service provided by the staff Don't second guess it, give it a shot, you won't regret it

Vinnies is like your favorite cousin. You love em, can't wait to see em, and always have a good time. From the vibes, the friendly service, and the killer slices, you can't go wrong with Vinnies. Ever.

The elote slice is an elite slice that you can find at vinnies. This shop is a simple shop that does things really well. The workers are nice and welcoming and they heat your slice up in record time. The flavors of the elote are amazing, and it's a super sexy slice to take pics of. Well worth it to slide by and grab a slice or two when you're in the city.

Grabbed a slice of pep after a lot of walking around. Nice staff and a few tables. They had a lot of interesting veggie options and some vegan. Simple easy option.

I'm not really into Williamsburg's hipster aesthetic or bougie yuppie culture, but I was hungry for pizza and noticed Vinnie's Pizzeria standing out among the rest. Maybe my childhood fondness for Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (TMNT) prompted me to walk in, and I was glad to see they had pizzas you wouldn't ordinarily find elsewhere. I tried the Mexican corn pizza, which they nailed--it was as sweet and savory as the actual dish. For $6, it was a little pricey, but I shrugged it off because the slice was excellent. I'm still a TMNT fan, as much of the comic and media represents NYC's goofy and colorful culture with retro art. This pizzeria feels like an old-school spot with a new generation running it. Part of me felt like a teenager hanging out at a cozy hangout. It's clean, the music is a mix of '60s and '70s Motown, and the diversity of the clientele and staff is noticeable. This place definitely has Turtle Power!